When Starbreeze announced they were pulling the plug on their ambitious co-op Dungeons & Dragons game, Project Baxter, it felt like watching a promising adventurer abandon their quest before even leaving the tavern. The studio behind the Payday franchise made the “difficult but necessary decision” to cancel the game and lay off 44 developers, all in service of doubling down on what they know best: heisting games. On the surface, this looks like smart business—focusing resources on your proven winner. But dig deeper, and you’ll find a story that speaks volumes about the current state of the gaming industry, where creative risks are becoming increasingly rare and corporate survival often trumps artistic ambition.
There’s something profoundly disappointing about a studio choosing to retreat into familiar territory rather than exploring new creative frontiers. Starbreeze’s CEO Adolf Kristjansson stated they’re “doubling down on what our players love—and what we do best—owning the heisting genre.” While this sounds like confident corporate strategy, it reads more like creative exhaustion. The gaming landscape is littered with studios that became prisoners of their own success, forever chained to the franchises that made them famous. What happens when players eventually tire of heisting? What happens when the genre that once felt fresh becomes stale through repetition?
The human cost of this strategic pivot cannot be overlooked. Forty-four developers—real people with mortgages, families, and dreams—now find themselves adrift in an industry that’s become increasingly hostile to stable employment. Starbreeze’s promise to provide “active support for affected employees to transition to new roles across the industry” rings hollow when you consider the current wave of layoffs sweeping through gaming. These aren’t just numbers on a spreadsheet; they’re artists, programmers, designers, and storytellers whose passion projects just got sacrificed at the altar of corporate strategy.
What makes this cancellation particularly painful is the lost potential of what could have been. A cooperative Dungeons & Dragons game from a studio known for multiplayer experiences? The concept alone sparks the imagination. Imagine gathering your party in a digital tavern, planning your next dungeon crawl, experiencing emergent storytelling that only tabletop RPGs can provide—but with the polish and accessibility of a modern video game. Instead, we’re left with another entry in the Payday series, a franchise that, while successful, represents a narrowing of creative vision rather than an expansion of it.
Starbreeze’s decision reflects a broader industry trend where established studios are becoming increasingly risk-averse. In an era of ballooning development costs and intense shareholder pressure, playing it safe has become the default strategy. But gaming has always been an art form driven by innovation and bold creative leaps. When studios stop taking chances, when they stop trying to create new genres instead of just “owning” existing ones, we all lose something precious. The cancellation of Project Baxter isn’t just about one game that won’t be made—it’s about the creative conversations that won’t happen, the innovations that won’t be discovered, and the magic that might have been but now never will be.
About the Author
