In the world of retro gaming, authenticity has always been the holy grail. We chase that elusive feeling of holding the original hardware, hearing the satisfying click of cartridges, and experiencing games exactly as their creators intended. Now, two competing visions for bringing Lego’s decorative Game Boy to life are forcing us to confront what authenticity really means in the age of preservation and recreation. On one side stands Natalie the Nerd with her Build A Boy kit, promising the genuine article through harvested Nintendo chips. On the other, the BrickBoy offers convenience and sustainability through emulation. Both approaches reveal fascinating truths about why we cling to retro gaming in the first place.
Natalie’s approach feels almost like technological necromancy. By harvesting chips from Game Boy Pocket systems and designing custom circuit boards smaller than actual cartridges, she’s essentially transplanting the soul of Nintendo’s classic handheld into Lego’s plastic shell. There’s something deeply compelling about this method—it’s not just playing Game Boy games, it’s playing them on actual Game Boy hardware, just housed in an unexpected new body. The requirement to modify some Lego bricks to accommodate the display adds to the sense that this isn’t a simple plug-and-play solution but rather a true fusion of two distinct creative traditions.
What fascinates me most about Natalie’s project is the philosophical statement it makes about preservation. In an era where digital emulation has become increasingly sophisticated, her insistence on using original chips suggests that there’s something irreplaceable about the actual hardware. It’s the difference between reading a perfect digital reproduction of an ancient manuscript versus holding the original parchment. Both convey the same information, but one carries the weight of history in its very material existence. Her warning that this won’t be something you’ll want to play daily speaks volumes about the practical limitations of this purist approach.
Meanwhile, the BrickBoy kit represents a different kind of authenticity—one focused on accessibility and sustainability. By using emulation rather than harvested chips, it avoids the ethical dilemma of sacrificing original Game Boy Pockets for their components. This approach democratizes the experience, making functional Lego Game Boys available to anyone willing to back the Kickstarter campaign. The tiered system—from essential grayscale gaming to full Game Boy Advance support—acknowledges that different users have different needs and budgets. It’s a pragmatic solution that prioritizes playability over purity.
As these two projects prepare for their 2026 and late-2025 launches respectively, they’re forcing us to reconsider what we value in our retro gaming experiences. Is authenticity about the hardware itself, or the experience of playing the games? Does using original Nintendo chips matter if the case is made of plastic bricks rather than Nintendo’s signature gray plastic? Both approaches have merit, and both speak to different aspects of why we preserve gaming history. Natalie’s method honors the original technology, while BrickBoy honors the original experience. In the end, perhaps the most authentic thing about both projects is how they capture the DIY spirit that has always been at the heart of gaming culture—the desire to take something familiar and make it our own.
About the Author
