When a game studio decides to kill a project, it’s never just about spreadsheets and quarterly reports. The recent cancellation of Starbreeze’s co-op Dungeons & Dragons game, codenamed Project Baxter, represents more than just another corporate pivot—it’s a story about creative dreams colliding with harsh business realities. For the developers who poured their passion into this project, the announcement that their work would be shelved to focus entirely on the Payday franchise must feel like watching their artistic child sacrificed at the altar of corporate strategy. The fact that this decision comes with 44 people losing their jobs adds a particularly bitter note to what Starbreeze CEO Adolf Kristjansson calls a “difficult but necessary decision.”
There’s something particularly heartbreaking about a D&D project being cancelled. Dungeons & Dragons represents the ultimate collaborative storytelling experience—a world where imagination reigns supreme and players can become anything they dream. To have that creative potential snuffed out by corporate restructuring feels like a betrayal of the very spirit that makes tabletop RPGs so magical. The gaming community has been hungry for more high-quality D&D experiences beyond the traditional tabletop, and the loss of what could have been a significant co-op RPG leaves a void that won’t easily be filled. One can’t help but wonder what creative visions and innovative gameplay mechanics died with Project Baxter.
The corporate language surrounding these decisions often rings hollow, especially when contrasted with the human impact. When executives talk about “sharpening focus” and “creating long-term value,” they’re speaking a language that doesn’t translate well to the developers who now face unemployment. The promise that Starbreeze will “provide active support for affected employees to transition to new roles across the industry” sounds reassuring in a press release, but anyone familiar with the current state of game development knows how challenging that transition can be in a market flooded with talented developers seeking work. The gaming industry’s constant cycle of hiring sprees followed by mass layoffs creates an environment of perpetual instability that takes a toll on creativity and morale.
What’s particularly telling about this situation is the timing and context. Payday 3 launched just last year to mixed reception, and now Starbreeze is essentially betting the entire company on making that franchise work. The plan to expand the Payday 3 development team to about 50 employees by the end of 2025 suggests the studio recognizes the need for significant improvements. But this raises uncomfortable questions about why the D&D project had to be the sacrificial lamb. Couldn’t both projects coexist? Was there no middle ground that would have preserved jobs while still allowing the company to strengthen its flagship franchise? The all-or-nothing approach feels particularly brutal in an industry that should value creative diversity.
The broader pattern here is one we’ve seen repeated across the gaming industry: the consolidation around proven IPs at the expense of new, potentially innovative projects. When companies become risk-averse, they retreat to what’s familiar, leaving experimental ideas and fresh IPs by the wayside. While focusing on Payday might make short-term business sense for Starbreeze, the long-term creative cost could be substantial. The gaming landscape becomes poorer every time a unique project gets cancelled, and the human cost—the shattered careers, the displaced talent, the broken creative spirits—represents a loss that can’t be measured on any balance sheet. As players, we’re not just losing a potential game; we’re losing the creative energy that could have fueled the next generation of gaming experiences.
About the Author
